No Holes Pool Fence®
No Drilling in the Ground
Is it as smart as it seems? See below.
No Holes Pool Fence® is a registered trademark of Guardian Pool Fence Systems, which has no affiliation with Life Saver Pool Fence™. This page is intended to compare traditional removable mesh pool safety fencing with Guardian’s No Holes Pool Fence® product.
Life Saver Pool Fence’s removable pool safety fence has been tried and tested for the last 40 years is installed by drilling a discreet 1 1/8” hole that is covered by a cap that matches the deck color when the fence is not in use.
No Holes Pool Fence® is a no-drill pool fence product offered by Guardian Pool Fence Systems. Unlike traditional removable mesh pool safety fences, which are installed using discreet deck holes and removable caps, No Holes Pool Fence® uses water-filled bases instead of drilled sleeves. While the idea of avoiding drilled holes may appeal to some homeowners, especially renters or those with unique deck concerns, it is important to understand the tradeoffs before choosing this type of system.
The primary advantage of Guardian’s No Holes Pool Fence® is in the name: it does not require drilling holes into the pool deck. The system uses 5” tall by 15” wide by 36” long plastic bases that are filled with water. Each base weighs approximately 65 pounds when filled. The pool fence poles are then inserted into the bases to hold the fence in place. Because the bases are heavy, Guardian’s No Holes Pool Fence® can be difficult to push over. Each standard 12’ long section weighs approximately 260 lbs.
Why Guardian’s No Holes Pool Fence® May Not Be The Best Option
Getting a pool fence without drilling holes comes with a number of disadvantages.
Storage
Because the bases are so bulky, if you choose to remove the pool fence to entertain or otherwise, a key feature of a removable pool safety fence, storing the entire system is very difficult. It will take up substantial storage space wherever you put it.
Expense
The temporary No Holes Pool Fence® is very expensive – more than 4 times the cost of a standard do-it-yourself pool fence. A typical 120’ no holes pool fence costs over $4,000 with shipping included. You can get the same fence on Pool Fence DIY for under $1,000. With that savings, when you are done with the pool fence, if the holes really bother you, even with the caps, you could get an entire new pool deck. The No Holes Pool Fence® price is even more than double the cost of a professionally installed pool fence, put in by a trained and authorized installer. That is a very large investment.
Warranty Is Not Lifetime
Most traditional pool fences come with a lifetime warranty. You would expect that the most expensive pool fence would be the same. However, the warranty on the currently available No Holes Pool Fence® is only 6 years. If you have more than one child, the No Holes Pool Fence® may not last as long as you need it. Life Saver Pool Fences have been used by multiple generations of parents.
Difficult to Remove
The makers of the No Holes Pool Fence® tell us that the no holes fence is much more difficult to take up and down than a traditional pool fence. Each of the water-filled bases weighs 65 pounds, so they have to be emptied before you move them (and the water inside is probably gross – more on that in a bit). Besides emptying the water, the fence has to be removed from the bases, and then both the fence and the bases have to be lugged to wherever you are storing them.
Yucky Water
The No Holes Pool Fence® requires that the plastic bases be filled with water from your typical garden hose. Over time, the water in the black plastic containers becomes putrid, growing mold, fungus, and who knows what. It’s definitely unsafe and should be kept away from children. When you empty the bases to remove the fence, you have to be careful that the water doesn’t go into your pool or come in contact with any landscaping or vegetation, not to mention any children or pets. Given that each base contains about 8 gallons of water, your standard 120’ fence, with 50 bases, will contain about 400 gallons of this really gross water that you have to dispose of… somewhere.
Bases Prone to Leaking
Several customers have reported that the plastic bases of the No Holes Pool Fence® are prone to leaking. Given the toxic nature of the water in the bases, this is concerning, especially in homes with pets or small children.
Custom Layouts
One of the great things about traditional pool fences is their flexibility. They can go up hills, up stairs, climb waterfalls, go around diving boards, and more. The No Holes Pool Fence® does not have the same flexibility. Because of the way it’s designed, it isn’t capable of going up stairs or steep hills.
Building Codes and Standards
The makers of the No Holes Pool Fence® report that their fence does not meet local building codes or national standards for mesh pool safety fencing. If you require your pool fence to meet code, this will not work for you.
There are good reasons why a No Holes Pool Fence® might be right for you, and any pool fence is better than not having anything at all. However, it is important to weigh all of the pros and cons before making your choice. If you are interested in discussing your pool fence options with an expert, give us a call at 1-800-282-3836.
Find Your Nearest Life Saver Pool Fence Dealer Today!
Make Your Pool Safer.
Receive a FREE no risk pool fence consultation.